so maybe been a while since I read the rules and maybe I am forgetting stuff but... isn't a nat 20 like saying 'you did an extra specially epic good job at the task' Not 'suddenly your pen that u were trying to sign your name has turned into a mega-nuclear bomb and turned the entire country into atoms' - cuz if that IS the new way the dice rolls work, doing ANY task would be a massive fucking risk.. ANYTIME u had to roll a d20 u have 5% chance of destroying all life.
That's more a Nat 1 kind of result, catastrophic failure. A Nat 20 is a Crit Success, so I'd probably say Worf phasers a nice clean passageway through the rubble with minimal time and no risk of collapse.
As is often the case in gaming comics, Worf just announces what he's doing and rolls without specifying what's being rolled. If the phaser is being treated as an attack, a natural 20 would be a critical hit in D&D, though that's just double damage to the target. But if it's a skill check, true. D&D 5E has no special rules for a natural 20 on those.
Hitting the wall was probably a foregone conclusion. I think the roll was just to determine how well it worked. Not that this is exactly how a natural 20 in D&D works under normal rules regardless, but I'm rules-lawyering a joke at this point.
If I say I want to non-lethally slap someone, and I roll a 20 and the DM says I just slapped the dude's head off and it exploded like a melon... Well I won't be happy
robnorrisradio
Methinks that worked a little too well
baldbear
Clear a path the Klingon way.
bbrtki
a 20 is a 20,. make it go boom!
AtmaDarkwolf
so maybe been a while since I read the rules and maybe I am forgetting stuff but... isn't a nat 20 like saying 'you did an extra specially epic good job at the task' Not 'suddenly your pen that u were trying to sign your name has turned into a mega-nuclear bomb and turned the entire country into atoms' - cuz if that IS the new way the dice rolls work, doing ANY task would be a massive fucking risk.. ANYTIME u had to roll a d20 u have 5% chance of destroying all life.
Racealistic
BlazeDragon777
Just happy
soulthreat
I dont know, those guys on legends of advantris are pretty fucking cool
JoeMalmsteen
That's more a Nat 1 kind of result, catastrophic failure. A Nat 20 is a Crit Success, so I'd probably say Worf phasers a nice clean passageway through the rubble with minimal time and no risk of collapse.
[deleted]
[deleted]
Revicus
As is often the case in gaming comics, Worf just announces what he's doing and rolls without specifying what's being rolled. If the phaser is being treated as an attack, a natural 20 would be a critical hit in D&D, though that's just double damage to the target. But if it's a skill check, true. D&D 5E has no special rules for a natural 20 on those.
abtei
wait? he fires first THEN rolls nat20?
i dont think thats the correct order....
Revicus
Hitting the wall was probably a foregone conclusion. I think the roll was just to determine how well it worked. Not that this is exactly how a natural 20 in D&D works under normal rules regardless, but I'm rules-lawyering a joke at this point.
PantsAreForTheWeek
Lyons?
Rufferstuff
Prune Juice.
PantsAreForTheWeek
Because Klingons love regular bowels?
HelloToe
Because it is a warrior's drink.
Whatdoyousaytoanicecupoftea
GLORY TO YOU AND YOUR REGULAR BOWEL MOVEMENTS
Rufferstuff
It's strong and bitter. Just like Worf.
PantsAreForTheWeek
Like Janeway and her coffee?
JoeMalmsteen
Pretty much, yes.
VariousTypesOfPurple
PHASERS DO NOT WORK LIKE THAT!
jethroismaxbaer5772
https://imgur.com/7Dd9OUd.png
supervillin
Valharroth
And here i thought phasers worked exactly how the plot needed them to.
astrangehop
My favorite is even with the pistol grip ones the beam just comes out at any old angle to hit whoever it's supposed to.
Dapperworth
GOODNIGHT!
VariousTypesOfPurple
I WILL DESTROY YOU!
shyriath
MrStealYourGiF
Rocks might though, if it's a splodey kind of rock.
Sechran
Could have hit a gas pocket too - common threat for miners, actually.
MrStealYourGiF
Or with all the timeline and dimension crossing, a pocket of naquadria.
Omnimorph2112
Neither does a Nat 20 roll. It's not a magnitude thing!
ThinkThisOut
It the notification to the DM that’s flavor text must be added
Mxlespxles
Cookiesnm1lk
or *do* they? well that and.... what if the dm says they do?
Omnimorph2112
If I say I want to non-lethally slap someone, and I roll a 20 and the DM says I just slapped the dude's head off and it exploded like a melon... Well I won't be happy
Quixus
If the DM and the players do not agree on a set of rules to play by you are not playing DnD, you are playing USA.
Cookiesnm1lk
hmmm.... fair enough. i concede this point. it's definitely better for everybody to agree on how to play the game.