You can still download delisted games on Steam and even Sony's game division honors this. I can still download Deadpool, Marvel Alliance, Transformers, and many other desisted games that lost their license on Playstation Network. So why are movies different? They are only removing the movies/shows from you online library, so as long as the media is on your system, they cannot remove it, but why remove access as well...
This entire discussion has helped me find what I think is the answer, or at least the difference. I.E. The "movies" and "shows"can be streamed or watched off your system.. you're losing access to the "Online library" While the "games" software cannot be streamed, and HAS to be downloaded to be played. THIS is probably what they're using as a loophole to deny consumers access to the media they purchased!
The part that really pisses me off (other than no physical disc) is that it automatically includes one month of GTA Online that will auto-renew until canceled. I have no interest in GTA Online, but think of the millions who will get the game, be excited to start playing, and will completely forget to cancel the automatic online recurring subscription.
For me? Nothing. They WANT it all digital because there is little ownership in the US anymore.
Not fucking buying it.
Sworn off Nintendo too with that bullshit.
Think we’ll see a game crash again. People won’t be able to afford the 1500 dollar consoles. And the more greedy stupid and lazy executives keep forcing this model, more and more game designers are going indie.
That’s my gaming future. Indie small creators and my classics where a physical copy matters.
Friendly (re)minder that GOG sells you the actual game files, so you can DL and install forever, the games can never be taken from you. Steam, Epic, and everywhere else only let you "rent" the games through their app, "promising" they will never take them from you.
Nothing *licensed* is every truly ours. That shit I downloaded in 2004 is still with me, tyvm, and resulted in me going to at least 6 live shows, which resulted in discovering multiple new bands and purchasing their music.
My first (and last) experience with losing shit i paid for was on Steam. Had Fallout 1,2 & Tactics- Steam decided to delete it and all but told me to kick rocks. Fuck 'em.
I know that it was delisted from the store but from what i read people who already purchased the game before that can still post in its forums and download the games
Reminder that "the cloud" is ultimately really just "some other dude's computer somewhere". That doesn't mean don't use it (offsite backup is a good thing), but stay a little paranoid about it.
so, quick search says this is "like netflix but you supply the video", so in order to have stuff to watch I gotta either build my own library or connect and stream from some rando person's PC advertised on a sketchy forum? Doesn't seem very convenient or secure
The setup is a bit obnoxious but not terrible, and after that it's pretty straightforward to add new media as long as you follow some basic folder naming rules.
Automating the new media part of it is the real game changer, id rather ditch plex and go back to VLC and a laptop with an HDMI cable than give up sonarr and have to download new episodes myself every week and keep track of new seasons these days. Freaking Simpsons just dropped their season finale on a random wednesday six months after the last episode aired. Even without the download scheduling sonarr is as powerful a renaming tool for tv shows as filebot.
If you want to replace streaming with your own stuff yeah you need a library, most users already have content so Plex or Jellyfin or whatever makes for a pretty frontend and simplified remote access. IDK why randos on sketchy forums would be handing out server access, but in that case on your end youd just be running an app on your TV or firestick or whatever, so theres no risk beyond using a sketchy chinese streaming stick yourself.
if you've already got content on your device, you just go to the folder where it is and you double click it and vlc media player pops up and starts doing its thing and then you watch it on the screen, no need for streaming. Aside from that, the primary purpose of streaming services is to find new stuff you haven't seen or heard of before which isn't the case with this, the whole point of a subscription fee is so I don't have to go a) learn about the show's existance and b) torrent it myself
Used to do just folders and VLC, this is an unequivocal improvement, Plex passes the wife test. 300TB+ of media is under my desk in my office, right now im in the living room watching everything ever on Adult Swim on (smart) shuffle on the big tv with a simple remote. Good luck getting HDR/DV and ATMOS to a TV from VLC too.
And if you cant find new stuff to watch without having a streaming service advertise it to you thats on you, people on here talk about shows and movies all the time.
Damn dude, ive got more content, but only a dozen or so friends and family. Id add more extended family but im waiting for my upload bandwidth to get upgraded. 2000 users tho, i assume shady commercial operation? Wish i could cash in on all my work lol.
Extremely high chance that much of that 185TB of data are clones of each other. Either slightly different encoded or outright 'renamed' files of identical original source.
lol... clones? That's straight unique file archive, all home grown, zero duplicates, and everything upscaled to 1080p or 4k. Around 200 or so 3D films as well.
Its really not much to manage with automated tools. My TV library is ~210TB, its ~380k unique episodes. Theres ~260 duplicate episodes in there, but most of those are different editions. And Tremors the Series i have in SD widescreen and upscaled fullscreen.
Because I don't have a different Blu Ray player. Also, those game discs are Blu Rays, and I'm not sure if the encryption key applies to all Blu Ray discs or just Blu Ray videos. I also know at least some Blu Ray players have internet connectivity, so they might need to update as well. The future is bullshit.
All. All things. A lot of people don't realise how quickly harddrives decay and stop working. We really are at great risk of losing most of the media created.
Those are rookie numbers. R/datahoarders will say you gotta juice them numbers ;-)
I'm finally at 96tb of raid with a zfs system. #teamneverdelete
Seriously though it was amazing to get rid of all my physical media. Especially disc technologies. Sold like... 100 DVDs to an older guy who almost cried when I said $5. He said he can't afford cable and things so goes to garage sales for stuff to watch. I went and dug up more to give to him.
Moved all my machines away from Windows over to Linux. Managed to bork my zfs up on the first go when two disks failed (they were shaky old drives) and I noobly tried to replace them. Forgot a command, didn’t have an export of my pool.
Luckily I had backed up everything twice (one being the zfs array, the other on a large disk) and had most of the originals too, so I was fine.
Ya zfs rocks! Lost partitions don't... Having all your computers and devices backed up and every single file across them all not taking up more space if they are the same is crazy. Same with snapshots. Features that would blow regular users minds.
Hard drives die. They dont last all that long either, dying Quicker than DVDs as well. The only genuine solution to the decay of digital media is pirating. Yes genuinely. So long as a copy exists on someone's harddrive, we're good. Join the group download chat and enjoy. Pirating is already morally correct, because fk corporations, but it is also actively a conservation effort.
You also might not. Discs rot, and depending on manufacturing technique and storage, you might very well not have your discs in 15 years. At least some of them are likely gone by then. If you care about conservation of the arts, the only viable method is actually collective sharing - aka, piracy.
Oh sweet. Its gotten so easy honestly. My preferes method: download qbittorrent. Then add its search plugins (guides online, feel free to ask me if you're stuck though). You can now directly search in the torrent program for whatever you're after, on All the sites who's plugins you've activated. Enjoy. On the topic of arts appreciation, and in the spirit of sharing, the best text on the topic is in my opinion "The Soul of Man" by oscar wilde.
Ya. Trying to catch up on the tech and safety measures again. I think the proliferation of streaming made a lot of us of a certain vintage lose some “muscle memory”.
And since the US only seems interested in protecting profits for companies, I don’t want bugs/fines/or lawsuits.
Trying to teach myself about VPN’s for the house and fam. Stuff like that.
All things rot. You’re not going to develop the only immortal tech.
But by the current timelines situation I’ll still be watching my unedited, theatrical filmed version of Star Wars without the Disney corpo cops coming in to force that digital monstrosity with the edits on me in the year 2036. I think it’s unrealistic to preserve art through the eventual heat death of the universe.
And I’ll have a direct source to rip the content and burn into my OWN digital content and burn them to blu ray.
tricerabottom
In the email they sent out, it has their “Play has no limits” motto at the bottom.
Seems to me like it very much has limits.
Vempire
Do what you want cause a pirate is free, you are a pirate!
forelle
Well that ripped .MKV file on my private jellyfin instance is not going away.
TerminalInterface
Arrr. what did you say matey?
TyrannusEquus
I bought it on steam, fair and square. If it's one day deleted, there is no moral objection to pirating it back.
forelle
Well that m
Nalianna
Yo ho ho.
Gryphonosiris
And this is why I have a literal wall of DVD's and Blurays.
Imadethisaccounttopost
You can still download delisted games on Steam and even Sony's game division honors this.
I can still download Deadpool, Marvel Alliance, Transformers, and many other desisted games that lost their license on Playstation Network.
So why are movies different?
They are only removing the movies/shows from you online library, so as long as the media is on your system, they cannot remove it, but why remove access as well...
Imadethisaccounttopost
This entire discussion has helped me find what I think is the answer, or at least the difference.
I.E.
The "movies" and "shows"can be streamed or watched off your system.. you're losing access to the "Online library"
While the "games" software cannot be streamed, and HAS to be downloaded to be played.
THIS is probably what they're using as a loophole to deny consumers access to the media they purchased!
IDoNotWantAnAccount
Piracy is preservation.
DRM only hurts legitimate customers.
Capitalism is detrimental to the preservation of the arts.
Goldensands
To its creation as well.
Cookiesnm1lk
"Capitalism is detrimental" there ya go.
draqsko
Don't worry, it was like that before digital distribution.
You literally don't own any software since the Computer Software Copyright Act of 1980. Go look it up.
clonedeeznuts
And people will continue to support Sony unfortunately.
NorrinxRadd
Im still pissed about dragon age, can't download the expansions I purchased because servers are closed.
wozat
Not sure exactly why the USAgent had to break the news
SpanWolf
Can't we all just agree to have the 551 movies deleted from ONE customer's account? Let Bob be the sacrificial lamb for all of us.
DiracsDelta
The bits on my hard drive are mine… should really do a stream capture of everything I’ve bought.
HamAdvocate
Nothing will ever beat the time Amazon deleted a version of 1984 from users Kindles.
BastardMan1977
Physical copy of GTA VI doesn't come with a disc....so what makes it physical?
discostewsm
Olivia Newton-John
TheFuckfaceWhisperer
The part that really pisses me off (other than no physical disc) is that it automatically includes one month of GTA Online that will auto-renew until canceled. I have no interest in GTA Online, but think of the millions who will get the game, be excited to start playing, and will completely forget to cancel the automatic online recurring subscription.
Umkontodon
your money is physical
DianNaoChong
Rumor is one with disc will come a couple months later to stim used game sales and leaks /street date issues.
somebackup
I'm sitting out GTA for this reason. Fuck that digital bullshit
enderite
For me? Nothing. They WANT it all digital because there is little ownership in the US anymore.
Not fucking buying it.
Sworn off Nintendo too with that bullshit.
Think we’ll see a game crash again. People won’t be able to afford the 1500 dollar consoles. And the more greedy stupid and lazy executives keep forcing this model, more and more game designers are going indie.
That’s my gaming future. Indie small creators and my classics where a physical copy matters.
meganical
Probably some code
DrewThe3DPrinterGuy
They don't really do manuals anymore for games so I guess it's all about that really swell box.
BastardMan1977
Yeah I'm not paying 80 bucks for a plastic box
ADMNtek
80 Bucks for an incomplete version, I might add.
BastardMan1977
Exactly
Imadethisaccounttopost
OH it gets worse, the RELEASE COPY doesn't come with a disc.
They do plan to release a disc copy, someday down the line.
https://www.vice.com/en/article/rockstar-games-responds-to-gta-6-physical-disc-backlash/
enderite
aeroldoth
Friendly (re)minder that GOG sells you the actual game files, so you can DL and install forever, the games can never be taken from you. Steam, Epic, and everywhere else only let you "rent" the games through their app, "promising" they will never take them from you.
Sebastopol140
BastardMan1977
ADMNtek
DrSchlepenstein
Link to the article. https://kotaku.com/playstation-store-movies-digital-studio-canal-terminator-2000711013
TomBrokaw
Nothing *licensed* is every truly ours. That shit I downloaded in 2004 is still with me, tyvm, and resulted in me going to at least 6 live shows, which resulted in discovering multiple new bands and purchasing their music.
W0lfsbl00d
*aggressively mid drummer in a good band's rage intensifies*
TomBrokaw
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-LDJzP4mDik
PotatoSalt
My first (and last) experience with losing shit i paid for was on Steam. Had Fallout 1,2 & Tactics- Steam decided to delete it and all but told me to kick rocks. Fuck 'em.
TheSocialRecluse
I know that it was delisted from the store but from what i read people who already purchased the game before that can still post in its forums and download the games
TheSocialRecluse
That wasn’t the case here?
PotatoSalt
It got deleted from my library. Wasn't hidden, under the wrong search or anything like that.
rubypilgrim
no sauce?
rubypilgrim
since no sauce, here's sauce: https://gamerant.com/playstation-store-deletes-purchases-no-refunds/
JustDumbCommentsAndCorrections
Reminder that "the cloud" is ultimately really just "some other dude's computer somewhere". That doesn't mean don't use it (offsite backup is a good thing), but stay a little paranoid about it.
tidepool
“The cloud” is that data center causing rust in the local pipes to poison the locals while they get less sleep because of the noise.
ForceAwakenWasLame
Cloud and backup copy of all on my ssd. Done and done
TheVillageGrouch9000
I don't use the cloud for storage. 14 TB of dedicated storage in my PC that gets backed up when the mood strikes.
ghostdrawn
I also have 14 Tb of movies and Tv shows on 2 seperate drives. 3700 movies and 175 Tv shows.
Imadethisaccounttopost
Amazon's been pulling the same shit for year - https://www.reddit.com/r/movies/comments/dn6wj5/just_fyi_you_do_not_actually_own_movies_purchased/
We need consumer protection.
foxmichaels
*laughs in pirate*
TheVillageGrouch9000
Aye!
Khanamana324
When buying isn’t owning, stealing isn’t theft.
enderite
Clockworkdancerobot
*polite cough*
SlavaUkrainisaysSteveBuscemi
not sure what this is....but I'm gonna go explorin a bit later....just 2,000 users with that much content....!!!! That is bananas, yo.
65454685132465846865163
so, quick search says this is "like netflix but you supply the video", so in order to have stuff to watch I gotta either build my own library or connect and stream from some rando person's PC advertised on a sketchy forum? Doesn't seem very convenient or secure
kevbot5000
The setup is a bit obnoxious but not terrible, and after that it's pretty straightforward to add new media as long as you follow some basic folder naming rules.
cyno01
Automating the new media part of it is the real game changer, id rather ditch plex and go back to VLC and a laptop with an HDMI cable than give up sonarr and have to download new episodes myself every week and keep track of new seasons these days. Freaking Simpsons just dropped their season finale on a random wednesday six months after the last episode aired. Even without the download scheduling sonarr is as powerful a renaming tool for tv shows as filebot.
cyno01
If you want to replace streaming with your own stuff yeah you need a library, most users already have content so Plex or Jellyfin or whatever makes for a pretty frontend and simplified remote access. IDK why randos on sketchy forums would be handing out server access, but in that case on your end youd just be running an app on your TV or firestick or whatever, so theres no risk beyond using a sketchy chinese streaming stick yourself.
65454685132465846865163
if you've already got content on your device, you just go to the folder where it is and you double click it and vlc media player pops up and starts doing its thing and then you watch it on the screen, no need for streaming. Aside from that, the primary purpose of streaming services is to find new stuff you haven't seen or heard of before which isn't the case with this, the whole point of a subscription fee is so I don't have to go a) learn about the show's existance and b) torrent it myself
cyno01
Used to do just folders and VLC, this is an unequivocal improvement, Plex passes the wife test. 300TB+ of media is under my desk in my office, right now im in the living room watching everything ever on Adult Swim on (smart) shuffle on the big tv with a simple remote. Good luck getting HDR/DV and ATMOS to a TV from VLC too.
And if you cant find new stuff to watch without having a streaming service advertise it to you thats on you, people on here talk about shows and movies all the time.
CrusherOfDreams
185TB of content, over 2,000 users, and growing by the day. Love my server.
cyno01
Damn dude, ive got more content, but only a dozen or so friends and family. Id add more extended family but im waiting for my upload bandwidth to get upgraded. 2000 users tho, i assume shady commercial operation? Wish i could cash in on all my work lol.
Micro2112
Hot damn that's a crazy user count. I share to like 5 people 😆
AtmaDarkwolf
Extremely high chance that much of that 185TB of data are clones of each other. Either slightly different encoded or outright 'renamed' files of identical original source.
CrusherOfDreams
lol... clones? That's straight unique file archive, all home grown, zero duplicates, and everything upscaled to 1080p or 4k. Around 200 or so 3D films as well.

cyno01
Its really not much to manage with automated tools. My TV library is ~210TB, its ~380k unique episodes. Theres ~260 duplicate episodes in there, but most of those are different editions. And Tremors the Series i have in SD widescreen and upscaled fullscreen.
Clockworkdancerobot
Damn, I don't manage that much, but then I only picked up a few 20TB HDDs. I have been buying DVDs and blu rays for years.
DianNaoChong
I wish I picked up a lot more 20tb when I could have. I'm running out of space fast and process are over the times normal
Clockworkdancerobot
I got some when they were $400, good enterprise drives. Now I spent $700 for just 18TB. ugh. Fuck Datacenters
Ac1dBurn72
Right? I picked up a 10tb a few years back for like $120. Now I'm running low on storage on that PC and I can't get 4tb for that price...
AyatollahBahloni
This is why my wife and I still have our DVDs and blu-rays.
DeltaBladeX
Blu Ray isn't safe either. https://www.flatpanelshd.com/news.php?subaction=showfull&id=1741331410
KaijuIsekai
Why tf are you playing blurays on a playstation?
DeltaBladeX
Because I don't have a different Blu Ray player. Also, those game discs are Blu Rays, and I'm not sure if the encryption key applies to all Blu Ray discs or just Blu Ray videos. I also know at least some Blu Ray players have internet connectivity, so they might need to update as well. The future is bullshit.
tidepool
This is why I’m a visitor of cs rin ru forums. Can’t lock me out of content if I refuse to use your proprietary garbage.
weidermeijer
… and CDs.
GabbyJayYay
plastikb0y
I have this. (not the collectors edition but on dvd. You got the TOUCH! Best movie intro ever.
ConstitutionalHeresy
Hell yeah brother! *pats his copy*
woodworkerf
But even these break down over time. 🤬
PutItInNeutral
So do most things you own.
Goldensands
All. All things. A lot of people don't realise how quickly harddrives decay and stop working. We really are at great risk of losing most of the media created.
MeowWoof
This is why I have a 24TB RAID array
justheretocommentonce
Nice! Anything you can recommend?
leviaton
Those are rookie numbers. R/datahoarders will say you gotta juice them numbers ;-)
I'm finally at 96tb of raid with a zfs system. #teamneverdelete
Seriously though it was amazing to get rid of all my physical media. Especially disc technologies. Sold like... 100 DVDs to an older guy who almost cried when I said $5. He said he can't afford cable and things so goes to garage sales for stuff to watch. I went and dug up more to give to him.
coughingintensifies
Hello there. I’m somewhat of a zfs user as well!
Moved all my machines away from Windows over to Linux. Managed to bork my zfs up on the first go when two disks failed (they were shaky old drives) and I noobly tried to replace them. Forgot a command, didn’t have an export of my pool.
Luckily I had backed up everything twice (one being the zfs array, the other on a large disk) and had most of the originals too, so I was fine.
Live laugh love! No wait… Live and learn!
leviaton
Ya zfs rocks! Lost partitions don't... Having all your computers and devices backed up and every single file across them all not taking up more space if they are the same is crazy. Same with snapshots. Features that would blow regular users minds.
mrthewhitee
This is why I have a hard drive full of mkv files.
Goldensands
Hard drives die. They dont last all that long either, dying Quicker than DVDs as well. The only genuine solution to the decay of digital media is pirating. Yes genuinely. So long as a copy exists on someone's harddrive, we're good. Join the group download chat and enjoy. Pirating is already morally correct, because fk corporations, but it is also actively a conservation effort.
Ravenwald
The plex server be plexin’.
10spen
Bastiroid
Switch to Jellyfin. Plex is doing some shady shit behind the scenes
Ravenwald
Done. Swapped and happy. Thanks for the heads up!
Krossis
https://media0.giphy.com/media/v1.Y2lkPWE1NzM3M2U1cmwzMHBpZngyeXF0enlod25ybDFpanpmMHhsdnhxeDVhYmF5MHB3cCZlcD12MV9naWZzX3NlYXJjaCZjdD1n/26FLgGTPUDH6UGAbm/200w.webp
enderite
Me too. Used to get lovingly teased by younger relatives.
“It’s nice uncle bill, but it takes so much room!”
Ya. But I’ll still have em in 15 years. You might not.
Goldensands
You also might not. Discs rot, and depending on manufacturing technique and storage, you might very well not have your discs in 15 years. At least some of them are likely gone by then. If you care about conservation of the arts, the only viable method is actually collective sharing - aka, piracy.
enderite
Oh, 100%!
I support exploring the seven seas. I have to relearn how to do it…. But people are losing their digital only content from companies NOW.
My dvd’s from thirty years ago still work.
Just a difference between time/scale of the emergency.
Should our species survive the next couple decades and we learn to appreciate the arts more, more can certainly be done.
Piracy now.
Digital libraries of content preserved. Libraries. Museums.
enderite
Later*. <—— somehow forgot to add that to the end there.
Goldensands
Oh sweet. Its gotten so easy honestly. My preferes method: download qbittorrent. Then add its search plugins (guides online, feel free to ask me if you're stuck though). You can now directly search in the torrent program for whatever you're after, on All the sites who's plugins you've activated. Enjoy. On the topic of arts appreciation, and in the spirit of sharing, the best text on the topic is in my opinion "The Soul of Man" by oscar wilde.
enderite
Ya. Trying to catch up on the tech and safety measures again. I think the proliferation of streaming made a lot of us of a certain vintage lose some “muscle memory”.
And since the US only seems interested in protecting profits for companies, I don’t want bugs/fines/or lawsuits.
Trying to teach myself about VPN’s for the house and fam. Stuff like that.
pyr0max
But those are also digital, so are they yours?
AyatollahBahloni
Well, unless they physically break in and steal them back, yeah.
enderite
I’m not sure the younger generation understands digital vs physical distinction in entertainment..
Goldensands
Nor do the older generation understand the inevitability of disc rot.
enderite
All things rot. You’re not going to develop the only immortal tech.
But by the current timelines situation I’ll still be watching my unedited, theatrical filmed version of Star Wars without the Disney corpo cops coming in to force that digital monstrosity with the edits on me in the year 2036. I think it’s unrealistic to preserve art through the eventual heat death of the universe.
And I’ll have a direct source to rip the content and burn into my OWN digital content and burn them to blu ray.