The only real question about education and political views is how did George W. Bush go to both Harvard and Yale and remain a Republican... but then you hear him try to say something and you know he spent his whole time at the frat drinking beer and only graduated because his dad paid for it.
It's important to remember that the US' "left" is what most of the rest of the world considers to be the middle, and that their right is what most of the rest of the world considers to be "far right"
Yep. The UK Conservative Party is politically closer to US Democrats than to US Republicans. In the UK the Conservatives proposed creating the NHS, legalised gay marriage, support climate change measures and built a huge amount of solar and wind power and so on. Issues like abortion, birth control etc just aren't issues here.
People who study how the world works find out it doesn't work the way conservatives think it should. That's why JD Vance just joined Joseph Stalin, Mao Zedong and Pol Pot in saying, "The professors are the enemy." https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=0FR65Cifnhw
How on earth did this dude manage to fool the entire world, myself included a while back ? Like, for while I considered him to be an intellectual individual. I'm now wondering if this dude actually needs the "do not eat" stickers on Legos.
I do find it odd that engineering is more split as engineers have to have really good critical thinking skills in order to be good engineers. Maybe all those red engineers are ones that got C’s in college
A lot of engineers have high IQ and applied skills, but lower social/emotional intelligence or overall knowledge of society and culture, necessary to understand society, economics, and even ethics. I can bet you countries such as Denmark or Sweden where education is more rounded have a lower right-wing percentage.
As an engineering professor for 20+ years, I say "fuck those conservative professors, they are a bunch of prima donnas that think way too highly of themselves." They cause so many conflicts in faculty discussions.
Conservativism is scientifically proven to be tied to lower cognitive abilities. And many of today's conservatives, including Musk, aren't even conservative, but regressive...
Yes, because they are teaching all religions generally. So like you might have a section on satanism, or wiccans, or hinduism, or a class on one of those things.
Its not the same as say professors who teach at a christian university, that would skew much farther right.
This by itself isn't good evidence being educated makes you liberal. We could have looked at a similar graph and with the same logic argued (wrongly) being white makes you better at academics. I have friends who are academics and the hiring is quite political, it would be silly to deny some departments are reluctant to hire open conservatives these days. Education does tend to make you more liberal though, this just isn't good evidence on its own.
When you see the people who vote for them, you can understand why they want to keep as many people as dumb as possible. If everyone had access to higher education the only people voting red would be the 1% of the population who are funding them.
There are literally studies that indicate the more education a person has, the more liberal their stance on societal issues. This information has been available for decades. Why do you think that in the USA Republicans have been basically waging a shadow war on education since the 1960's? Their attacks on education have only become more open in recent years.
Ultimately, a lot of conservative stances are based around wanting to maintain a status quo that is beneficial to an elite few. In order to support this, you have to either be the elite few OR be convinced that an outside source keeps you from being the elite few. This is ultimately a non-logical position, there are countless other factors that any amount of higher education clears up because you've inherently learned how to research and read statistics.
Everything I see posted from republicans I still know I look up. They never post full context, only the part they like. If they posted the rest then they’d look like an idiot
I've traveled and lived in various regions of the US. The general public in the SE and other red states tend to be waaaaay less educated than in other regions.
IME you get some pretty socially weird people in engineering and a lot of people that don't seem to see the value in practicing empathy regularly.
Not shitting on engineering, I am an engineer and have met some great people in my field. But I have noticed a trend with some people in my industry (obviously this is speculation based off my anecdotal evidence so definitely take it with a grain of salt)
Plenty of people go into engineering and want to work for a place that will pay them a shitload of money, regardless of the outside impact. Oil/Gas industry, Defense, etc.
Institutions of higher learning have always leaned more liberal - that's why higher learning has always been the target of fascist and totalitarian regimes.
Absolutely. Educated progressives seek and embrace the objective truth and are compelled by their knowledge to spread it and bring light to humanity.
Primitive conservatives, on the other hand, are repulsed by the objective truth and try to spread manipulation, lies and superstition around, their goal is to undo progress and instill fear, hatred and ignorance. They are SO EVIL!
I would argue the old maxim: those who can’t do, teach. Academia is an ivory tower of out-of-touch non-contributors. All of the conservatives are out manufacturing and building. Liberal are holed-up in the safe spaces of universities and laboratories. Very far removed from reality.
Which is funny cuz on the back end professors love to bitch about kids these days and play traumalympics and count meritocracy points and be snide about people that go into industry "just for the money? Really?"
To be completely fair, this is a measure of political party, and while racism definitely leans right, the left is far from removed from having racist members.
Also you can distinguish between four big groups of racists. First the obvious one who believe they are the superior race (a lot of them are also thinking they have the superior religion). Second the xenophobes who are afraid of the unknown. Third the people afraid that migrants will take their jobs. And last the intolerant who think their culture is in danger because of migrants. I think the third and fourth group are most likely to change, but also have the most "logically sound" fears. That
Is the main thing we should tackle. No the immigrants will not steal your job. No they won't "make" YOU change cultural things. However there are chances they change the culture by bringing new types of food, customs, religions, etc. Just like for instance Italians changed the culture of people in the past.
Having spent a significant portion of my career serving ultra rich clientele in the hospitality sector I can tell you that you are significantly overestimating the average intelligence, education, and worldliness of the 0.1%. For real though, some of the dumbest and most ignorant motherfuckers I've ever met. Turns out that having just about every single thing handed to you in your life, including credentials and "accomplishments," will basically cripple your ability to grow.
Sociopathy can read as racism, particularly when those wielding power and influence attempt to deepen class divisions (originally built by blatant racism). Racism takes away economic opportunity while sociopathy blames the poor for being poor.
originally built on blatant racism, in TURN originally built on economic rationale. The advent of “race” in a contemporary sense comes around the time of Bacon’s rebellion, where virginian landed gentry begin to recognize “We have to divide class solidarity somehow so that workers wont side with slaves in future rebellions and threaten our economic dominance
This is also where you see a sharp curtailment in indentured servitude, as many servants were european and thereby “white,” and the notion of “White people should be free laborers” begins to cement in the minds of the bourgeoisie of the colonies.
A very high amount of chemical engineers end up in the oil & gas industry. And mechanical engineers wind up working for the defense industry. All play heavily into republican policies.
Lots of engineers on the older side didn't get the title with education, but with working on the same thing for decades. My dad worked with several engineers who only had a high school diploma but worked on helicopters for 30 years and so got that engineer title for the pension bump when they finally retire(d). That option has been destroyed, though, so don't worry, we won't be letting experience get in the way of permanent debt anymore.
I think this is all made up bullshit. You're telling me that 100.00% (Note the specificity, which would indicate less than 1 in every 20,000) professors in Comms and Anthropology are dems and 99.99% of RELIGION profs are dems? This smells like some fresh bullshit.
Looking at the link on the graph gave me the paper. Their data starts with the USN&WR top 40 Liberal Arts colleges, which excludes all state universities, Yale, Harvard, MIT, etc. Example colleges: Vassar, Sarah Lawrence, Bryn Mawr…all very lefty, and mostly cater to humanities. The Vassar Bio dept. is probably more lefty than, say, U of Tx. Also not shown in the graph: 37.8% of faculty at the colleges studied who were not registered under any political party.
I realize that. My dad has a PhD in religious studies and is kind of a neolib moderate dem. But I refuse to believe that 99.99% are dems, when we have so many explicitly christian colleges and universities. I've done lots of statistics in social sciences and you never see "99.99% of [x group] is [y]. It just never happens like that.
It says the sample size was 5,116. I doubt any of those were outside of large institutions, or from specialised colleges, like "christian" colleges as that would heavily skew the data.
soulseekbob2320
Could someone explain this to me ?
🤔🤣
Hovencl00f
Educators are by occupation interested in the advancement of others.
fakefucknfireplace
So close to getting it……
horseWnoname
cool...now do other professions, like banking and law
Selerox
Brexit Comparison: Low education level was directly linked to voting for Brexit. Educated people voted Remain.
RelentlessDevastation
Amazing what side you choose when you're intelligent
glovelyday
YpsilantiRomani
Yeah but Republicans live on that 1st peak of the Dunning-Kruger chart
Terran4543
Elon musk only retweets stuff and says "true" or "wow" or whatever. What a joke of an absolute garbage person.
Gelflingus
The only real question about education and political views is how did George W. Bush go to both Harvard and Yale and remain a Republican... but then you hear him try to say something and you know he spent his whole time at the frat drinking beer and only graduated because his dad paid for it.
Rockstarwizkidd
Devil's advocate... this is almost pre-trumpism. Also roughly inverse to the general pay scale of those educational backgrounds.
Samja192
It's important to remember that the US' "left" is what most of the rest of the world considers to be the middle, and that their right is what most of the rest of the world considers to be "far right"
CarlBassett
Yep. The UK Conservative Party is politically closer to US Democrats than to US Republicans. In the UK the Conservatives proposed creating the NHS, legalised gay marriage, support climate change measures and built a huge amount of solar and wind power and so on. Issues like abortion, birth control etc just aren't issues here.
SuitcaseJefferson
I don't think this is the "own" he thinks it is.
sleeperkid
koops
And there it is. It’s like finding the tool gifs logo.
copperdomebodhi
People who study how the world works find out it doesn't work the way conservatives think it should. That's why JD Vance just joined Joseph Stalin, Mao Zedong and Pol Pot in saying, "The professors are the enemy." https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=0FR65Cifnhw
usingYourMomAsAHat
How on earth did this dude manage to fool the entire world, myself included a while back ? Like, for while I considered him to be an intellectual individual. I'm now wondering if this dude actually needs the "do not eat" stickers on Legos.
SLCtechie
I do find it odd that engineering is more split as engineers have to have really good critical thinking skills in order to be good engineers. Maybe all those red engineers are ones that got C’s in college
Snarkoleptic
A lot of engineers have high IQ and applied skills, but lower social/emotional intelligence or overall knowledge of society and culture, necessary to understand society, economics, and even ethics. I can bet you countries such as Denmark or Sweden where education is more rounded have a lower right-wing percentage.
hellospacemonkey
As an engineering professor for 20+ years, I say "fuck those conservative professors, they are a bunch of prima donnas that think way too highly of themselves." They cause so many conflicts in faculty discussions.
AnOceanOfStars
Conservativism is scientifically proven to be tied to lower cognitive abilities.
And many of today's conservatives, including Musk, aren't even conservative, but regressive...
ScienceIsNotALiberalConspiracy
It still amazes me at the number of advanced-degree STEM graduates who still believe in ghosts and Magical Sky Wizard.
clashatdemonhed
The more you learn, the more you realize all you don’t know. Some people find comfort in sky wizards, and that’s ok.
MarioBoon
Religion professors are democrats?
EternallyIgnorant
Yes, because they are teaching all religions generally. So like you might have a section on satanism, or wiccans, or hinduism, or a class on one of those things.
Its not the same as say professors who teach at a christian university, that would skew much farther right.
richardstinks
Republican art professors? Do they cut their own budgets?
nojustsayitdont
Leopards. Faces. You know the how the story goes.
Arbitrarynamehere
Surprised at 11% poli sci. They've got no excuse lmao
Nalianna
Well, someone has to design hostile architecture - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hostile_architecture
ladybuglauren
Lol
Copperbrat
This isn't evidence to a conservative. It's ammunition. They aim to dismantle public education and make access to higher education harder.
jmmsharp
This by itself isn't good evidence being educated makes you liberal. We could have looked at a similar graph and with the same logic argued (wrongly) being white makes you better at academics. I have friends who are academics and the hiring is quite political, it would be silly to deny some departments are reluctant to hire open conservatives these days. Education does tend to make you more liberal though, this just isn't good evidence on its own.
Gelflingus
When you see the people who vote for them, you can understand why they want to keep as many people as dumb as possible. If everyone had access to higher education the only people voting red would be the 1% of the population who are funding them.
dudehiemer
There are literally studies that indicate the more education a person has, the more liberal their stance on societal issues. This information has been available for decades. Why do you think that in the USA Republicans have been basically waging a shadow war on education since the 1960's? Their attacks on education have only become more open in recent years.
existentialdetective
Sounds like the kind of argument an educated PROFESSOR would make!
ladylambi
same with Conservatives in Canada :/
AranaDiscoteca
Ultimately, a lot of conservative stances are based around wanting to maintain a status quo that is beneficial to an elite few. In order to support this, you have to either be the elite few OR be convinced that an outside source keeps you from being the elite few. This is ultimately a non-logical position, there are countless other factors that any amount of higher education clears up because you've inherently learned how to research and read statistics.
L4dead2
I was groomed republican being raised. I got educated and it opened my eyes to the rest of the world. That’s when I stopped being a republican
Audasity
funny thing too, it takes minimal research to debunk about 60% of republican talking points
L4dead2
Everything I see posted from republicans I still know I look up. They never post full context, only the part they like. If they posted the rest then they’d look like an idiot
Audasity
and you start questioning specific parts of it, and they just deflect and say 'why cant we just have our separate beliefs' or yell and scream at you
paddleup
I've traveled and lived in various regions of the US. The general public in the SE and other red states tend to be waaaaay less educated than in other regions.
VibratingNipples
“Goose-stepping morons like yourself should try reading books instead of burning them!”
joshuasplinth
Mmm, yes, DOCTAH JOOOOOOONES!!
thekeyofe
homoerection
Pilgrymm
I went in for engineering and came out an Anthropologist. Applied forensics.
SneakyGaryTheSerialHorseDrowner
If you're not a supervillain then this is the biggest waste of a backstory since Game of Thrones S8.
Pilgrymm
Cool thank
JoeMangoJello
What the fuck is wrong with engineering? Why is it failing so hard by allowing evil to thrive?
Narwhilian
IME you get some pretty socially weird people in engineering and a lot of people that don't seem to see the value in practicing empathy regularly.
Not shitting on engineering, I am an engineer and have met some great people in my field. But I have noticed a trend with some people in my industry (obviously this is speculation based off my anecdotal evidence so definitely take it with a grain of salt)
Kemi337
Plenty of people go into engineering and want to work for a place that will pay them a shitload of money, regardless of the outside impact. Oil/Gas industry, Defense, etc.
fractalsphere
Institutions of higher learning have always leaned more liberal - that's why higher learning has always been the target of fascist and totalitarian regimes.
HelloToe
Fengor
We can't give in to the thinkers!
phillybhatesme
Reality skews left
chewybrian
People who try to see the objective truth about the world are harder to control with bullshit
Margrave9000
Absolutely. Educated progressives seek and embrace the objective truth and are compelled by their knowledge to spread it and bring light to humanity.
Primitive conservatives, on the other hand, are repulsed by the objective truth and try to spread manipulation, lies and superstition around, their goal is to undo progress and instill fear, hatred and ignorance. They are SO EVIL!
alcaray
That statement may confuse cause with effect.
jbrightmans
Cultural Revolution, China (1966-1976)
NooPogodi
Reality leans towards the left
zbobet2012
As a leftist you're going to have a rough time explaining Pol Pot and the Cultural revolution
LincLoud
Look at the "cultural revolution" in China for how universities were treated
cgabgedchabbachange
Educated prolitariat is a scary thing.
kaarbaakimgr
I would argue the old maxim: those who can’t do, teach. Academia is an ivory tower of out-of-touch non-contributors. All of the conservatives are out manufacturing and building. Liberal are holed-up in the safe spaces of universities and laboratories. Very far removed from reality.
StellaMatutina
Which is funny cuz on the back end professors love to bitch about kids these days and play traumalympics and count meritocracy points and be snide about people that go into industry "just for the money? Really?"
fartharder
Facts have a left leaning bias
werrywerry
Reality itself leans left.
zubax
Ya, it's a bit tough to be racist when you learn more about the world.
paullyboy1999
It's a bit tough to not be a racist if you aren't a piece of shit human as well
TheOneAndOnlyButtStabber
Going over seas to another country will tear away the blinds from peoples eyes. Sadly stupid people typically cant afford to go to these places
LisaSimps0nsDr3aM
… also it’s hard to root for the guys that wanna cut your funding and dumbing-down your junior scientific staff.
EverNotRelevant
And yet Thomas Sowell happened
SteveTheEgg
To be completely fair, this is a measure of political party, and while racism definitely leans right, the left is far from removed from having racist members.
Hoogemast
Also you can distinguish between four big groups of racists. First the obvious one who believe they are the superior race (a lot of them are also thinking they have the superior religion). Second the xenophobes who are afraid of the unknown. Third the people afraid that migrants will take their jobs. And last the intolerant who think their culture is in danger because of migrants. I think the third and fourth group are most likely to change, but also have the most "logically sound" fears. That
Hoogemast
Is the main thing we should tackle. No the immigrants will not steal your job. No they won't "make" YOU change cultural things. However there are chances they change the culture by bringing new types of food, customs, religions, etc. Just like for instance Italians changed the culture of people in the past.
tavinjer
Well, the obvious solution here is to not allow yourself or others to learn more about the world, duh
nik282000
[The 0.1% has entered the chat]
burningeagle
What percentage of people are narcissists...
maeta
Much much more than that
Clockworkdancerobot
"We know about the world, we just don't care. We're racist as fuck. Why else are we doing nothing on climate change?" --The Rich
Blud4BludGod
Having spent a significant portion of my career serving ultra rich clientele in the hospitality sector I can tell you that you are significantly overestimating the average intelligence, education, and worldliness of the 0.1%. For real though, some of the dumbest and most ignorant motherfuckers I've ever met. Turns out that having just about every single thing handed to you in your life, including credentials and "accomplishments," will basically cripple your ability to grow.
Beanholio
Sociopathy can read as racism, particularly when those wielding power and influence attempt to deepen class divisions (originally built by blatant racism). Racism takes away economic opportunity while sociopathy blames the poor for being poor.
casualgenderquestion2718
originally built on blatant racism, in TURN originally built on economic rationale. The advent of “race” in a contemporary sense comes around the time of Bacon’s rebellion, where virginian landed gentry begin to recognize “We have to divide class solidarity somehow so that workers wont side with slaves in future rebellions and threaten our economic dominance
casualgenderquestion2718
This is also where you see a sharp curtailment in indentured servitude, as many servants were european and thereby “white,” and the notion of “White people should be free laborers” begins to cement in the minds of the bourgeoisie of the colonies.
notacobra
The most surprising thing about this is the percentage of conservative engineers.
Sanguinius4893
Well I mean any good engineer knows that when doing calculations, it's best to be conservative.
AtlasMorrow
Engineer here. Honestly, I expected more republicans. That was my experience.
Override9636
A very high amount of chemical engineers end up in the oil & gas industry. And mechanical engineers wind up working for the defense industry. All play heavily into republican policies.
madeejit
Mechanical engineers build weapons. Civil engineers build targets.
SuperPickle17
also they are very highly paid positions... driving the very much "fuck you i got mine" attitude.
Tellenue
Lots of engineers on the older side didn't get the title with education, but with working on the same thing for decades. My dad worked with several engineers who only had a high school diploma but worked on helicopters for 30 years and so got that engineer title for the pension bump when they finally retire(d). That option has been destroyed, though, so don't worry, we won't be letting experience get in the way of permanent debt anymore.
Ninjainslippers
I think this is all made up bullshit. You're telling me that 100.00% (Note the specificity, which would indicate less than 1 in every 20,000) professors in Comms and Anthropology are dems and 99.99% of RELIGION profs are dems? This smells like some fresh bullshit.
TheobromineAddict
It's well known that a thorough examination of the world's religious texts leads to atheism.
neptix
Note that religious studies and theology are two radically different things.
seedye
Looking at the link on the graph gave me the paper. Their data starts with the USN&WR top 40 Liberal Arts colleges, which excludes all state universities, Yale, Harvard, MIT, etc. Example colleges: Vassar, Sarah Lawrence, Bryn Mawr…all very lefty, and mostly cater to humanities. The Vassar Bio dept. is probably more lefty than, say, U of Tx. Also not shown in the graph: 37.8% of faculty at the colleges studied who were not registered under any political party.
Delabouilliederizquisourit
The survey is on 5000 people only
Gelflingus
There are a lot of people who study and teach "religion studies" who are not conservative Christians.
Ninjainslippers
I realize that. My dad has a PhD in religious studies and is kind of a neolib moderate dem. But I refuse to believe that 99.99% are dems, when we have so many explicitly christian colleges and universities. I've done lots of statistics in social sciences and you never see "99.99% of [x group] is [y]. It just never happens like that.
HaikuSorrow
It says the sample size was 5,116. I doubt any of those were outside of large institutions, or from specialised colleges, like "christian" colleges as that would heavily skew the data.
Gelflingus
Not that it would be the first time he shares obviously fake "info" for his cult to gobble up but yeah you're right, the number is unlikely