372242
3648
204
Since Gravity's release, there have been fan theories that Stone does not live to make it back to Earth, but instead dies at some point during the film and the events we see are a hallucination. There are varying theories on the time and cause of Stone's demise. Some say everything after she drifts off into space and Kowalski never rescues her, others say she is consumed by the fire in the ISS, or that she drowns in the lake. I've even read a theory that the entire film is a dream, and that Stone dies in a car crash when she learns her daughter has died.
The most popular theory is that Stone dies of hypoxia (lack of oxygen) when she turns off the oxygen in aboard the Soyuz. Here is the evidence for this interpretation:
Loss of Consciousness
As the oxygen supply in the Soyuz dwindles, Stone loses consciousness. Everything we see after this point is in Stone's head as her dying brain tries to make sense of her body's physiological state.
The White Light
A common element of Near-Death Experiences is seeing a white light. It is not unreasonable to assume that those who do die experience similar symptoms to a NDE except they, you know, die. In this case, Stone's face is illuminated by the light from Kowalski's helmet.
The Hallucination
A symptom of both hypoxia and NDEs is hallucinations. In NDEs, people often report seeing a holy figure. However, it seems that Stone is an atheist as she says she's never prayed in her life. Stone instead sees Kowalski who represents a father figure, and like most figures in NDEs, he's dressed in white.
The Decision
Another common trait of NDEs is the feeling of reaching a decision point as the person must decide whether to live or die. The question is presented to Stone by Kowalski: "do you want to go home or do you want to stay here?" Stone chooses to live, but unfortunately it's highly-unlikely that a person who has lost consciousness due to a lack of oxygen will regain consciousness without medical intervention. Stone continues dreaming.
Tiangong
Stone's next stop after the Soyuz is the Chinese Space Station called Tiangong, which literally translates into English as "Heavenly Palace".
Euphoria
Stone is noticeably more cheerful after speaking with her hallucination of Kowalski than she was at any point before it. Euphoria is a common symptom of hypoxia.
Hot Flashes
A less common symptom of hypoxia is alternating feelings of hot and cold. Stone mentions that is is getting hot aboard the Shenzhou as it begins to reenter Earth's atmosphere, and during its reentry a fire breaks out.
Seizures
A severe symptom of hypoxia is a seizure. The Shenzhou capsule shakes violently while Stone is in it.
Dizziness and Nausea
More signs of hypoxia represented by the Shenzhou's spinning during reentry.
More White Lights
During her final descent, Stone is once again sees white lights.
Feelings of Suffocation
The smoke from the fire aboard the Shenzhou begins to suffocate Stone, and in her hurry to escape the fire she opens the hatch allowing water to rush into the cockpit. When she escapes the capsule, she is weighed down by her suit and is at risk of drowning. Stone's blood oxygen is depleted.
One Final Thought
Stone resurfaces in a lake surrounded by beautiful, lush green hills. She hears birds and insects as she crawls to the shore, stands up and begins walking. Her final thoughts are of an untouched paradise, and the film cuts to black as her brain dies.
Avengur
Or, lights are bright and white in space and using the atmosphere as a brake tends to heat shit up. Refer to one of my other top comments.
AnotherImgurianEnglishman
All I see is a lot of characteristics of re-entry being tenuously linked to hypoxia. The cabin shaking is siezure? Oh come on.
TheDogEnd
You know what else feels hot? Fire in adjacent pods. You know what else shakes and spins you? Your space shuttle falling to Earth.
Buretsu
Or maybe you're reading way too much into it, and she actually does get back. Maybe the cigar is just a cigar.
pooploops
lol good effort at trying to attach a plot to a movie that had none.
PeterME
All the reentry stuff is physics. Leaving it out would be a mistake. And Tiangong is the actual name, "heavenly palace" is just an apt name
IBleedBlueBlood
I just watched this tonight for the first time... And reading this post brings me back to high school English and all of the over symbolism
parallaxis
The Author is Dead
welcomestranger
I just liked that her final challenge was gravity itself.
hailthefish
Makes more sense than taking the events of the movie literally.
housewife
What? This movie was a metaphor for the dealing with the pain of losing a child and making the choice to go on living and 'return to earth'.
thelostskeleton
"But maybe they really died, and here's evidence of the hallucination" is like the most base-level assumption I've seen for anything.
naMretupmoC
Thank you for a neat interpretation to -what I though- was an amazing movie :)
Twenben
Neat interpretation indeed. I don't get all the hate in top-comments. I wouldn't say amazing movie though, but definitely worth watching!
Galactasaur
I need to watch this again now.
PartyMagician
So George Clooney is God. Got it.
dreamspeak
how can gravity be real if the film isn't real?
Iamahugefanofcamembert
yes. i for one am not even touching the floor at the moment!
iamkirbatron
We see you jaiden.
cogit
She has trouble standing up at the lake - a symptom of living in space as muscle atrophies, but not of hypoxia. Theory dead.
whotheFUCKletthedogsout
This post was written by every English teacher I have ever had.
Realmanbaby
... i'm an idiot. I thought you meant how well the grammar was done.. NOW I get it.. *fails at life*
crispymartyr
According to my sophomore English teacher, any character with the initials J.C. is Jesus. No matter what they do. Always Jesus.
acunninglinguist
I am Jesus.
TheSwedishCryptid
Jay-C
mitanni
JC Denton is Jesus? What a shame...
coincidenceithinknot
As someone who writes and is well out of coll, some things really are done intentionally.
eggmuffin
Absolutely. I truly enjoy reading a well constructed metaphor. This, however, is not one such. And that, I think, is the point being made.
VeryMagical
TIL I am Jesus. Coo'
Hibi
Like when Bobby from King of The Hill met Jimmy Carter?
housewife
I think themovie was a metaphor for the dealing with the pain of losing a child and making the choice to go on living and 'return to earth'.
notouchingNOTOUCHINGnotouchingNOTOUCHING
I agree with this.
Realmanbaby
Hey, that's actually a good analogy! +1
JediKnight
Best interpretation for this film I've heard yet. And fitting with Cuaron's other film's themes. Children of Men, A Little Princess...
batterrie
I like this way better than the actual post.
ExistentialCat
Agreed!
ilikefoodmorethanpeople
what makes it more English-teachery is that Quaron personally explained a lot of these scenes, and the meaning is completely different
housewife
DO you have a source for that? I have some interpretations myself and would like to check them out.
ilikefoodmorethanpeople
1st- sorry for misspelling Cuaron's name. 2 I saw an interview w him on tv, you can start by reading this-
ilikefoodmorethanpeople
http://www.vulture.com/2013/10/alfonso-cuaron-answers-your-gravity-questions.html
famouslyficklefartington
There is gravity to what you say
LOTNorm
If the caption says "Gravity's ending", it's probably a good bet that--if you haven't seen the movie--you should just hit the right arrow.
JasonD
LEFT ARROW REPRESENT
castleinthewind
Saw the beginning of the movie, but couldn't make it past the first 45 minutes of this tripe, so I appreciate the spoilers.
PenisApologies
A lot of thought went into this. +1
CrapSac
I haven't watched the movie yet, so I'm going to assume the real ender is Sandra knocking on my front door.
Funlovingsociopath
with beer and pizza
induren
No the real Ender is some Polish military genius... different movie, friend.
CrapSac
I CAN'T WAIT
LDedlock
Happy Birthday!!
MakingUpAUsernameIsTerrifying
My favorite alternative interpretation of Gravity is the superfluid vacuum theory
croaky
I love you
TacoPuncher
link? cause I feel like it can't be explained in 140 characters
MakingUpAUsernameIsTerrifying
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superfluid_vacuum_theory
garuffthehorse
whut?
TacoPuncher
thank you
croaky
Psst. It's a physics joke.
TacoPuncher
gah physics, I no do good physics. hurt brain, break brain
croaky
Nuuuuuu! Physics is so good!
TacoPuncher
physics for wise men, with skinny arms.
YouLookingAtMe
I'll bite. What is that?
croaky
Physics biiiaaaaatch!
PadraigS
I don't think anyone's paradise would be filled with bugs.
NerdN1
Distant sounds of bugs like crickets and cicadas don't really spoil a paradise. Spiders crawling all over you on the other hand...
plazmatyk
Timon and Pumba's would!
ALLOFTHEBACON
I REALLY ENJOYED WATCHING SANDRA BULLOCK CRY AND SCREAM AS SHE FLOATS THROUGH SPACE. FOR AN HOUR AND A HALF.
OfCourseLuke
I really can't figure out how serious you are
crimsonslate
This is the most accurate review of the movie.I hated the movie due to none of it able happen in real life but they played it out to be real
spacemosphere
OR MAYBE IT WAS A MOVIE
Jilian
Guys! Guys... I think they're onto something!
HeyThereBruce
i watched it...in 3d....did not like it
LetsSeeHowThisGoes
WHAAATT??? There is always a deeper storyline in every story right?
WhiteWolfSix
Sometimes a bird is just a goddamn bird lol
LetsSeeHowThisGoes
it if walks like a duck, talks like a duck and looks like a duck its a duck!
Cobaltios
A duck is still a bird.
Solastro
It was a documentary right?
bigtuna1125
We need her totem to wobble at the end to tell us. Otherwise we'll never know.
SashaTheGray
I always upvote Inception.
SargentSarcasm
Someone already pointed out why he wasn't dreaming at the end of Inception.
tinyplaidninja
*shakes 8 ball* Not Likely
baronridiculous
YES DON'T THINK LOL JUST ABSORB MAN WHY ARE YOU PEEPLES SUCH NERDS WITH YOUR THINKING AND IDEAS AND FANCYNESS JUST SHUT UP AND STOP CARING.
SwedishRationalist
How does that change anything in this post?
Ijustwannachange
Nah man, if it's not 2deep4u it's not good
pipstop
Thank you, one think I hate is over analysis
LoneDirewolf
Why does everything have to have a second meaning. Andy's mom and now this. Can we just enjoy the movie
dundundunnnn
You really can't enjoy the movie now just because someone else had fun with the same movie in a different way? its odd.
senshu
All good art does have more to it, a true point beyond the superficial. Discovering it seems to be a lost art, itself.
symphonyofnames
This enhances my enjoyment of the movie. People put a lot of work into these.
HatsAreEssential
To be fair, the Andy's Mom thing was more than likely real, given how many easter eggs Pixar likes to hide in their movies...
BlueHillyo
http://www.disneygeekery.com/2014/02/25/emily-not-andys-mom-in-toy-story/
Harcorepkurharcoreprkur
Really? That entire theory seemed VERY reaching to me. A : The hat's weren't the same and B: Most adults in the 60's had the same toys.
parallaxis
But movies are entirely about deeper meanings, symbols and allegories.
DamnTheseElectricSexPants
i wouldn't say "entirely"
jexsam
Not necessarily; like any art, the bulk of its meaning is only what you get from it even if what you get isn't what the artist intended. 1/?
jexsam
If all you get is a few laughs, that's all it is. If you get a deep allegorical message, then that's what you get. Art is subjective. 2/2
Cobaltios
We can choose to ignore them if we want to. Makes our heads hurt less.
parallaxis
That I can agree with.
sowaitwhatdidyousaytome
Andy's mom? Sauce?
Ijustwannachange
really really stupid shitty click bait tier shit
Solastro
WHY DID YOU HAVE TO BRING THAT UP
LoneDirewolf
Don't get me started on the whole, "Every Pixar movie is connected" thing
TranssexualUnicorns
You sound very disgruntled by the situation
Cobaltios
Haha, that's cute. As if they really are connected xD.
TheBaconSurfingCanuck
This shit also happened with ME3 and that stupid IT ending. I don't get people's fascination with things being deeper.
MaroonBunyip
I don't get people's anger with trying to know and figure out more.
TacoPuncher
In all fairness the theory does have some validity
TheBaconSurfingCanuck
No, it doesn't. A lot of the evidence is false or can be explained.
TacoPuncher
Like what evidence is false?
eronth
Because whenever someone finds a LEGITIMATE deeper meaning everyone goes apeshit and loves it, so now everyone wants to find meaning, so...
eronth
people now love anything that's remotely plausible as a deeper meaning to something they enjoyed!
NotReallyJustKiddingIfOffendingAndNotACompliment
Wait. No. What?! That was just a ... a movie? Holy shit - I thought the Nespresso-guy died...
JCrashB
Lol, read it in Louis CK's voice: "...but maybe...it was just a fucking movie!"
TheDevilMadeMeDoIt
THANK YOU. Some people need to figure out where the line is between discovering symbolism and rolling in bull shit.
TwinkleTwinkleLittleShit
But thats what makes a good movie. I like movies that tell a different story when you focus on details...
dundundunnnn
YEAH, why cant everyone think like me!
MeSoMerry
I don't have a problem with symbolism, but I feel like people say every goddamn movie is a dying hallucination
GuybrushThreepwoodMightyImgurian
This
malaroo
These "they were dying and it was a hallucination" theories are so stupid. You can do it with pretty much any movie and it's lazy as hell.
SovietWrench
I think it's true for Mulholland Drive, but that's the only movie it really works for.
baronridiculous
This is a valid criticism. "Itz just a stories LOL" is not. "Why cant's just watch movie and not think so much, duh." Jesus.
kugnae
Eh, sure. Why not.
LearningOnImgur
Every time I see a post like this, I immediately think "Oop, found the English major who thinks his degree is worth something!"
jeoffkrey
This is what I like to think movie makers say when people over analyze their movie
Rikoshi
I personally feel like this requires far too much reaching and doesn't really fit the theme of the film, or Stone's character arc.
terbril
Absolutely. The theme of the film was wholly about overcoming these challenges. It would be meaningless to have her die.
Harcorepkurharcoreprkur
Yup. IMHOP it just wasn't a deep enough movie to warrant all that. I walked into the theater expecting more.
hippocampus
I took the whole journey metaphorical. some kind of cleanse for her anxiety. clooney as some kind of spiritual guidance. (1/2)
hippocampus
but all of these action scenes and explosions didn't help my approach (2/2)
Harcorepkurharcoreprkur
Yeah, I also couldn't really get over how cliche it all was. BIG surprise she had a kid that died......yawn.
wysguy
As someone who's been in a hyperbaric chamber (pilot school, yo!) I can confirm how euphoric being without oxygen can make one feel!
MeSoMerry
M'lady
aviatorzz
I felt drunk, my fingers were tingling, I got super hot, and couldn't think straight when I did the same thing. UND!
wysguy
Oh sweet! I ended up picking Arizona State for school, but I did the aviation summer camp at UND. Lived in the dorms, etc. Super cool!
hitlershairydick
I read hyperbolic time chamber, I'm more satisfied with that.
Sakkura
Do you mean hypobaric chamber? AKA altitude chamber - it's the opposite of a hyperbaric chamber.
wysguy
Oh snap... Yes I did. Thats what I get for commenting at 1 am. Haha
osamulius
Genuinely curious: Can you explain what that means and why you were in one for pilot school? I want to become a commercial pilot.
wysguy
Awesome!! Chase your dreams! Its used to simulate if you had a gradual loss of cabin pressure... Everyone's reaction is different. (1/2)
wysguy
You get to see what your body does in reaction to being without oxygen. I get super tingly and I feel like laughing my head off. (2/2)
GabZonY
what the fuck is the evolutionary purpose of that
CathNought
Don't fear the reaper :)
stinkycheezmonky
Hyperbaric chambers don't get rid of your oxygen, they force more in...
Sakkura
My guess is it was hypobaric, not hyperbaric.
wysguy
Yeah my bad. I meant hypo. :)
ThatsMySecretCapImAlwaysHorny
Don't do oxygen kids!
MRCOCKSMASH
RedPandaGranda
This is heavy
OfCourseLuke
Haha. Because Gravity.
TheCutestSloth
There's that word again! Heavy!
TheTrueFreemo
This is... not a Back to the Future reference is it, Doc?
Smayds
Why is everything so heavy in the future?!
BrassKicker
Scientists increased the Earth's gravity by a factor of 1.667