BardockTheRebel
407265
6390
182
This is not the weirdest lightsaber I've seen.
A lot of people have an almost OBSESSIVE anger towards the lightsaber seen in the trailer of Episode VII. I was included, but I've come to realize it wasn't *that* bad. There has been terribly and unorthodox collection of lightsabers.
A quick explanation
Sith lightsabers were usually constructed using a synthetic crystal. These crystals were man-made, and exchanged control for greater cutting power. These crystals could be created wrong, making them unstable.
If you've played the Forced Unleashed, you know about unstable crystals. They have less of a firm blade and more of a consistency of fire. This explains the flickering of the Sith in the trailer's blade.
The Saberstaff
If you've ever seen Episode I, you know about the saberstaff. It was designed with two blades and one hilt; like a staff. However, Darth Maul's saberstaff was very different than the original saberstaff. Exar Kun, the creator of the first saberstaff used a Sith holocron with the blueprints. These blueprints instructed the creator to use a standard size hilt, not the elongated hilt like those used by Darth Maul or Bastila Shan.
Imagine trying to use Exar Kun's staff. You'd think you would have to use it with two hands. You could, but it was best wielded with one hand. You had to constantly spin it in your hand, usually above your head. That would need some serious training just to get used to the way you had to wield the damn thing.
Darth Nihl's Lightsaber
Darth Nihl didn't appear until Darth Krayt's Sith Empire, so you might not know him. However, this Sith Lord had a lightsaber that had an elongated handle and a standard size blade.
This was a large lightsaber hilt and a blade equal to any other standard lightsaber. While Nihl could use the blade, it wasn't as effective and clunky as crazy. You would have to train with this thing all the fucking time. And even then, it would still be overly clunky and overall inferior to a standard lightsaber.
Asajj Ventress/Komari Vossa's Paired Lightsabers
These lightsabers were curve hilted and paired lightsabers. Curved lightsabers weren't too unorthodox. They would fit better into the palm, allowing for better control.
Paired lightsabers weren't unorthodox either. They were similar built sabers that could conjoin at the hilt, making a saberstaff. But...
...Ventress's saberstaff had an "S" curve. This was unwieldy even to itself. Ventress knew how to wield it effectively, but anyone would see this as too tricky to master.
Maris Brood's Lightshotos
In the Force Unleashed, Maris Brood wielded a pair of Lightshotos. A shoto was supposed to be a blunt weapon, not a blade. So, what's with Brood's lightshotos? Very difficult to master, not very effective unless you know these things like the back of your hand.
Githany's Lightwhip
This was a stringy lightsaber that needed to be wielded like a whip (obviously). Once again, difficult to master. If you can't wield a regular whip, then you'll more than likely cut your own limbs off.
MonkeyWithAPun
I just don't have the heart to tell OP that this is all make-believe.
GoDDstopper
An intervention may be easier. We can yell "intervention!" At him. it'll be fun. We can drink boxed wine out of diet coke cans.
SeveralSeditiousScribesFromCaesarea
You need to monetize your knowledge of star wars :P
Aspel
I'm glad someone else realized that strange lightsaber designs are par for the course.
DarkMagician96
I know I am an ignorant little bastard for asking this, but where can I learn all off this additional Star Wars stories/eras
Mexikan4Life
same here
pointlesssteel
Yeah spend loads of time on the wiki and buy books or comics if they seem very interesting.
crea7or
This saber guard is fu*ing useless. How it should looks like:
feor1300
best theory I've heard is that the metal parts we see are just hollow so he doesn't slide his hand up into the blade
cansolo
Exactly what I thought. Nice to see it visualized.
johnny5alive
These would both function in the same way though... Or did you also not know that there are materials that light sabers can't destroy?
DarthFirebolt
yeah and mining them in the required amounts to make a lightsaber is highly improbable. also nulled by disney saying the EU doesn't exist.
johnny5alive
Not exactly. The change was that the EU no longer is canon unless it is reiterated by films. the writers can incorporate EU if they wish
crea7or
Really? Never heard that light saber material is such a strong thing.
johnny5alive
Yeah there are a whole bunch of them http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Category:Lightsaber-resistant_materials
crea7or
Anyway the version without tubes is nicer.
StructureLlama
Because of the way the lightsaber beam is focused, that simply couldn't be. I swear there was another similar post on here that explained it
Kalen
I think the cross guard is a brilliant idea. Ever fought with sticks and smashed your fingers? Protect the hands!
TooCthulhuForSchooloo
I wouldn't use a cross guard that cuts my hand of if I tilt the weapon slightly. I think it looks cool and that is what's important.
JudgeJudyandExecutioner
The problem is that the cross guard projectory bits stick out, so a light sabre could just cut through them. So they're kinda pointless.
narwhalhosting
Saber resistant materials exist.
charlie2979
All the saber resistant materials are now non-canon. Mandalorian iron etc. doesn't exist anymore.
Almainyny
You're implying that Disney didn't simply make up their own versions of such a material.
charlie2979
They probably will and i hope they do. But for now everything in this post is non-canon.
narwhalhosting
Unless they exist in the new movie.
charlie2979
But the new movie isn't out yet. So at this point in time saber resistant materials are non-canon.
Abbelinkin
This style is from the old republic. Its a hilt and not new. Anyone read the expanded universe???
charlie2979
EU is non-canon now. Only films and the clone wars cartoon are canon.
MaraJadeSkywalker
But they can still take stuff from EU and make it canon.
charlie2979
But at the moment it is non-canon. If they then bring it in good, but for now this post is pointless.
SrCigaro
Does that include Path of the Jedi and Book of Sith? Cause i'll be trully disapointed if it does.
charlie2979
All EU is non-canon, only the films and clone wars tv series is canon now.
SrCigaro
Yeah, but the PotJ and BoS are more like, the mithology of the universe. Those that mean that all mithology can be remade?
charlie2979
Yeah. Disney will probably just remake certain parts of the EU with their own spin on.
andrewjpf
Correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't a shoto a short bladed weapon? Like a mini katana? Maris Brood's weapon seems more like a tonfa.
EmeraldPeanut
You are correct, Maris Brood's saber is a tonfa.
fartingpinetree
I'm confused why anyone would be mad over new original ideas after seeing episodes 1-3
AttorneyAtLager
As if 4-6 had no original ideas.
EducatedTanuki
Jar Jar was a new idea
fartingpinetree
Jar Jar was an attempt to recreate a indiscernible companion like chewy
CHUBMARINES
Jar Jar was originally designed by GL to be a merc and betray QuiGon at the end of the movie. Someone else decided otherwise
BigJu
I would have made him betray. We would have better reasons to hate him
Sirolfus
actually that would've completely redeemed the character
iamgrr
That would have been awesome. Still have him be the stupid, weirdly voiced, good guy, but at the end you find out that he's a bad ass merc.
NotaLizardmen
Episodes 1-3? Never heard of 'em.
napsmear
Where's the Light Sickle that Darth Farmer used?
Madmacattack
Darth comrade use light sikel an hamor, you of wrong
webbus
to all the downvoters of this post
IAmJacksViagraInducedErection
And on a side note...Anything is a dildo if you're brave enough
shmehh36
+1
Onlyhereforthelaughs
Was expecting a lightsaber with a red downvote.
iamireland
But you do, because you stopped to comment on it, even finding a gif.
webbus
haha true dude. the force is strong with you
AssManProctologist
it seems like quite a bit of fuck to give actually
diphenhydraminehcl50mg
That was just for the points ;)
backtobackpanicattack
Yeah, get used to the wars. The Star Wars. This place will be awash with 'em for quite some time...
didanax
Except everything else but the movies is no longer canon. I feel sorry for the Star War scholars who just had their string theory taken away
Brononomous
God I love all the Starwars nerds coming out of the dark corners of imgur now makes me want to go read all the books again.
hmsbeagle404
As someone who wants to read the books but doesn't know where to start - which books and in what order?
Daik07
Read the Thrawn Trilogy!
Brononomous
Look up the x-wing series by Michael A Stackpole it is 10 books so a bit large but its very good and a great place to start.
dougiefresha
Darth plaguies (don't know how to spell it), and Darth Bane trilogy
WhiskersTheWondercat
Replying to keep track of the info (I am not an organized person)
MauricioGuaura
Depends. Do you care about the canon? A New Dawn.
BillColv
The Darth Bane trilogy is very good, and lore-important for the movies in direct ways. (I know nothing about the other books.)
AtalanBeardy
Uhhh... Isn't that non-canon now?
BillColv
Unless rescinded, contradicted, or otherwise retconned by future movies, I really don't care.
zerdath
... there are books?
lordblood123
the recently non-canon EU is fucking huge dude.
zerdath
ACTING! :D
lordblood123
?
zerdath
Nevermind...
I6ify
A shoto is a short sword, a tonfa is the weapon you were thinking of.
AllIHaveHadTodayIsLikeSixGummyBearsAndSomeScotch
Isn't the Shoto the wooden training version of the Wakizashi? But you're right, that picture shows a tonfa.
ObscureReference2501
you're thinking of a bokken. tanto, shoto, and daito are just different size blades: 1ft, between 1ft and 2ft, and 2ft or more respectively
AllIHaveHadTodayIsLikeSixGummyBearsAndSomeScotch
So what's the difference between Shoto and Wakizashi or Daito and Katana respectively? I only know one word for Tanto^^
ObscureReference2501
tanto, shoto, and daito only describe blade length, many knives and swords fall into each catagory. katana and wakizashi are specific swords
AllIHaveHadTodayIsLikeSixGummyBearsAndSomeScotch
Ah I see. Thanks for the information :)
kibu
You forgot the dual phase sabers. Such as Corran Horn's. Horn's saber had a stud on the handle that would cause the blade length to double.
xochiluvr
Ass to ass.
broafoflead
OMG NEW HILT DESIGN IS DUMB http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Crossguard_lightsaber It's not new.
Imtheguywhogetsawaywithit
It's not new, but it's still dumb.
Applecrow
This.
ApotheosisCM
To be fair though, a lot of the stuff in the EU is dumb. Imagine Marvel movies with half the shit from the comics. People would be laughing.
AtalanBeardy
Good thing almost all of it is non-canon, including the explanation in the OP!
WhiskersTheWondercat
Half the shit in silver age marvel comics would make most audiences scratch their heads raw
whatweretheythinking
And then there's all those resurrections: Noo, RDJ died! Oh wait, there's this magical transdimensional sometingsomething. Ok, great!
ohnoanotherputz
Like furry tree lizards that can stop force powers. You could just strap one to your head and bam, Jedi can't touch ya.
Sauroctonus
I, I like ysalamiri. D:
badapparu
The Jedi can still stab you. Or shoot you. Which is why people don't really do that.
[deleted]
[deleted]
MethelyneBlue
He was being sarcastic on the "OMG NEW HILT DESIGN IS DUMB" part.
CharmingAndSexyGentlemanStarshipCaptain
What
DaveTheMurderingHippo
I'm thinking it was sarcasm...
chainletter
OMG HILT DESIGN IS DUMB*
ihatechoosingausername
But this describes a hilt with a second blade at a 45 degree angle. The new one has 3 blades. 2 as handguards at a 90 degree angle.
PolskaKielbasa
'new'
dalescherrypie
Actually it really isn't dumb, protects your hand (like a real sword). But it's constructed wrong in the trailer.You would just cut the hilt
kukiraz
There's plenty of material in the star wars canon that is resistant to light sabers though.
dalescherrypie
Then it would make sense to make the crossguard solely out of this material and not both laser and said material. Still dumb constructed
kukiraz
Yeah, it could be seen as silly or excess, but in my opinion there should be SOME room for things that are there because it looks cool.
dalescherrypie
True. But I personally think it would look cooler with the crossguard only out of laser
madmattz
A whip... Yep thats beyond dumb haha
TheAlphaHipster
there are light saber resistant materials in the star wars universe. A suit made of that and a light saber whip could work
Pandaemonium001
yeah agreed, especially since a lot of whip techniques have you wrap the whip around your body after you whip it.
CharmingAndSexyGentlemanStarshipCaptain
Then don't wrap it to your body....
Pandaemonium001
sorry whip tricks, like show techniques that i know of
CharmingAndSexyGentlemanStarshipCaptain
In my country there's an island where people there use whip extensively. They never wrap it on their body ever.
Pandaemonium001
and i believe you but ive only had expereience with show whipping and part of what they do is maneuver the whip around their body
chainletter
I would assume it's used like an Urumi (whiplike sword, Indian). But that's still a very silly sword.
Bpdrummer
You guys DO know it's not real right....?
ethernel
No problem with the force,telekinesis,jedis not feeling that Palpatine is a sith.This light saber comes along and everyone loses their shit?
vindik8or
Uuuuugggghhhh. Just stop.
Berethian
Except this is almost all non-canon.
StarWarsAndMassEffect
Yes, but they can still use whatever they want from the EU, making that thing canon again :)
Berethian
Sure, but you can't use the EU as evidence of canon for a new thing.
StarWarsAndMassEffect
True...
lordblood123
story is non-canon. Tech is sorta in limbo.
Berethian
Tech is non-canon until otherwise confirmed, surely?
lordblood123
well its sorta complicated but it should be treated as in limbo. Assume the possibility it could be there till otherwise.
Berethian
The possibility is always there, though. For anything. Including that Mandalorian bullshit.
lordblood123
which mandalorian lore? I'm a Traviss fan but i accept with a bitter heart that her lore was overridden by the show.
CharmingAndSexyGentlemanStarshipCaptain
ITT: Star Wars ubernerds vs fucking casuals.
theadventuresofpuddles
Not as cool as flying casual, peasant..
DI2EAD
Nerd level over 9,000
CatrionaShadowleaf
So all I got from that was "it's not the usual shit, so it's really really hard to learn and you'd have to train forever." For all of them.
aldriel
Sith and Jedi start their training very young.
CharmingAndSexyGentlemanStarshipCaptain
well, they are supposed to be Jedi and Sith, fighter monks extraordinaire in space battle opera.
DinosaurArmyMajor
There is absolutely no way I would still have arms and legs in the Star Wars universe.
eronth
Ha! He thinks he'd be a jedi.
DinosaurArmyMajor
Nope, street rat in Coruscant's undercity. It's cool, I'm sure I could still find a way to lose my limbs.
nation543
the thing that a lot of people don't know about the SW universe is that people who can use the force build their light sabers by hand (1)
nation543
and that the color is purely based on the crystal that they use. red, white, yellow, purple, green - it's all the crystal.
Aspel
You have to be psychic to use a lightsaber in the first place. Jedi are able to use them due to the force, anyone else'd kill themselves.
NotARope
Except Boba Fett.
TrijezniMujo
Just stick with a good blaster, can't fuck up there.
kpmatias
Tis but a scratch...oops wrong fandom
SwagOutTheAss
Get outta here, you rat! You hear me! Leave!
Jzot
I fart in your general direction!
NerdN1
This is why lightsabers were only used by jedi, everyone else thought they were crazy dangerous. And they were right!
iamsparticus
I would, I'd be a civilian of some sort. Gotta remember the percentage of people that were jedis even before the great massacre was small.
Lardy
theres no way id have my knees in the lego star wars universe
paultheoctopus
Only Siths deal in absolute.
kootiepatra
It's okay, neither did Darth Vader.
TwoEdgedSwordfish
Not your original, organic limbs anyway.
aureolus
Most people don't lets be honest. Except Obi WAN. you know, b?
ThePsychicZombie
I'm pretty sure a lightsaber would cost more than anyone other than a Jedi could afford anyway.
UserSubmitted
I wouldn't last more than 2 minutes weilding the lightwhip
Spanked84
Don't worry. You probably wouldn't become a Jedi, anyway.
AgonistAnt
NerdN1
Lightsaber safty: http://darthsanddroids.net/episodes/0777.html
backtobackpanicattack
With your username, I'm now picturing a T-Rex wielding twin light sabres and giggling. Wait, I am giggling, not the T-Rex. Okay, maybe both.
DinosaurArmyMajor
http://imgur.com/ZuuBgGl
IDontKnowHowToHuman
He looks more like he's ostrich-laughing than giggling.
backtobackpanicattack
[giggling intensifies]
Idontknowhername
On the bright side you can replace with sweet robot arms and legs
DinosaurArmyMajor
This bright side you speak of, I shall embrace it. Robot arms and legs could seriously increase my killing power.
CatsIsTheAnswer
Just don't play holo-chess with wookies...
DinosaurArmyMajor
Haha, just make sure the Wookie wins :)
NerdN1
http://darthsanddroids.net/episodes/0779.html
Armored0Titan0
Well if you're a Sith you're probably 60% cybernetic enhancements to begin with.
DaveTheMurderingHippo
No......... but ok
AmericanAirlines
Pretty much my exact reaction
EpicPublixCustomerServiceStaff
Haha noice
DaveTheMurderingHippo
EpicPublixCustomerServiceStaff
That's a generous slice of blue pie
jashley62
Goes down well with a generous glass of blue milk.
EpicPublixCustomerServiceStaff
xD noice
SwordInTheInkwell
Very few people did anyway, after being in close proximity to a jedi or sith.
pictureofthatoneguywhenpeoplegetupsetatsarcasticcomments
What were the ratios like of jedi/sith/saber wielding people populations, to non j/s/swp's in the Star Wars universe like?
Nalrus
Couldn't tell you how many Jedi there were, but assuming the following the rule of two, there should only be two Sith.
pictureofthatoneguywhenpeoplegetupsetatsarcasticcomments
Wait are you telling me that at most points in time there were only 2 Sith in the universe?
Kightsbridge
2 sith lords, 1 master and 1 apprentice, however there are many that call themselves sith.
Nalrus
To my understanding, the Sith created the rule to stop infighting amongst the members as they felt it was what made the jedi so weak 1/?
SwordInTheInkwell
Well it's just an guess, but I would say at least 1:2. Maybe even 1:3.
IDontKnowHowToHuman
So at least 1/3 of people in the entire SW universe are jedis?
SwordInTheInkwell
Well, I'm no expert. But yes.
DarthTurducken
...said Anakin
[deleted]
[deleted]
LeslieKnope2016
Shutting him down before he's had a chance to fly. Cold blooded.
NotACanadian
He could always enlist into the Empire.
TheTrueFreemo
Straight outta Coruscant!!!
Tothebadcommentsection
Proton missiles fired!
DinosaurArmyMajor
I'm happy with being a street rat, just as long as it wasn't in Gungan City.
TheLordLucifersBannedAccount02
Why not? Not a good swimmer?
DinosaurArmyMajor
I swim pretty good actually. I'm also quite clumsy. And no-one likes me. Fine, I'll live in Gungan City, I guess.
TheLordLucifersBannedAccount02
Ah. Yeah, definitely not Gungan city. I thought it was because you hated JarJar. His own people hated that klutz. Not the place for you.
[deleted]
[deleted]
Sirolfus
Well, shit
Robobax
Alderaan**
IntentiomalTypo
Aladdin*
TuskenRaidURoRRuRRR
I always wanted to live in the SW universe until I realized I would probably be a slave
NotACanadian
Yeah, lifestyle-wise, Star Trek would probably be a better place to live because of all that utopia jazz. Star Wars is cool but pretty
NotACanadian
much everybody in there that isn't government or Jedi is super poor.
EchoOfSnac
If I were to chose a universe it would be Harry Potter's. If I didn't get magic I would probably just be the same as I am now.
TheLordLucifersBannedAccount02
I would choose Star Trek. At least that way, if I'm no-one important, I wouldn't die in the streets.
[deleted]
[deleted]
spacecowboyein
tasha grew up constantly on the run from rapists and stuff. probably a lot of bad colonies to be born in
disinformatique
You'll end up as a Red Shirt.
ProfessionalHugDealer
By that logic, what's to say you aren't already in the Harry Potter Universe?
EchoOfSnac
What's to say that I am not already a wizard and I am just trying to act like a muggle to protect our secrets?
DurgaSyn
These few strange designs aren't representative of the whole EU, saying that we're better off without it being canon just because of things/
lngwlkr
I don't understand. What does the European Union have to do with this? Is it because bad guys have British accents?
DurgaSyn
Like this makes me sad, there's a lot of really good EU books and games that you're writing off when you say stuff like that
WeMissYouCeraGuy
I'm still angry at Disney to this day.
FSMPirate
Although, there is the most orthodox http://imgur.com/uFQMHYF
saywouldyoulikeachocolatecoveredpretzel
This is not the first time I've seen that image, but it's by far the best time.
rectalprolapse
This is simultaneously my first and my best time. Although I guess I wouldn't know until my next time.
thescarydude
You win at the internet for today.
grimoirine
hey man, http://imgur.com/Pd8v19j
DonaldTrumpsPubicCombover
Star Wars: Revenge of the Jews
BrandtKadin
Chuckled then swiped right. Then swiped left and came back just to upvote this genius
[deleted]
[deleted]
FSMPirate
Sorry friend, but I have a hard time believing that you made the original. However, you did find it before me, so I upvoted the post :)
westonsymes
Well i did i post it before anyone else and if you look at my other pictures they are all photoshops so yes i did make it
KaiKaiTheBoringGuy
Commenting for future use.
poeticallybored
I saw a gif version of this a couple days ago and can't find it now. Anyone have a link?
DarthTurducken
Took me a few seconds
thewidowsson
I see what jew did there
swaptrick
I see what Jew did there.
colorandcontrast
That would actually be pretty effective! *pokes*
bendeem
jew power, yay for hanukah, do you think he can make latkas on that saber
eviscera
STAHP. I'm in a meeting. My boss is here. I am biting my tongue so hard to not laugh...
Dooood
To be honest, it isn't his fault. Perhaps that's not the best time or place to view imgur.
eviscera
Oh you party pooper you.
Dooood
Well, I try not to be a party pooper, I just try to choose where the party might be more appropriate. Then it can be a full-fledged party!
SnowballVonPorkenzollern
There are some who lay claim to that
pronacc
Decimated means to reduce by 10%. So it's really not that much, unless you're talking about the population of Vietnam from '54-'75.
SteevyT
Wtf?
pronacc
Sorry wrong comment.
SomebodyStoleMyCarRadio
Now I'm really interested what else is going on right now on imgur
Pencillin
srsly
TanstaaflTovarisch
I have yet to figure out why the crossguards are a big deal to anyone. So what?
jaijaikali
They'd get cut right off if another lightsaber slid down the hilt, plus self-harm and its looks stupid.
HeyCasButt
In reality the absence of a crossguard on the original lightsabers was more of an annoyance to me.
MrBananaBeak
Because they aren't effective crossguards. They can be cut right off.
RichieYesitsSpelledRichieNotRitchieNotRichey
You guys know that there are materials that can resist lighhtsabers, right?
will242
There are a few extremely rare materials that resist the cutting force of the lightsaber if made into the hilt emitters they won't be cut
SirStylus
This is true, but relies on extended universe knowledge which I doubt will be easily accepted by average fans.
will242
They never wondered why people would come at jedi with the cortosis weave electrostaffs and they wouldn't be cut
SirStylus
I think that was high sci-fi enough for most people to think 'well it's like a lightsaber, I guess?' because it glowed. But point made.
K1ngFiasco
Exactly. WE DON'T KNOW WHAT THEY DO YET PEOPLE. Remember the first time you saw Maul extend both blades!? There could be more to this saber.
nihilityfarce
As a competitive sabre fencer, it's a big deal. The crossguards would be hella useful and I'm glad they included them.
twentyfiveandone
I disagree with all the hate, but the argument is that there is no point to having it since lightsabers can't "slide" against each other.
CowboyZ
Where did get that idea? A New Hope and AOTC and ROTS all showed sabre blades sliding against each other.
thatlamer
It still stops a blow that would have otherwise targeted your hand/fingers, not the blade itself.
Noobity
With the number of hands getting cut off in star wars I'd think jedi would have thought of this millennia ago.
TanstaaflTovarisch
I recall Obiwan and Vader locking blades in A New Hope. The bladed crossguard would have been handy for Vader at that point.
imadethisaccountforthisthing
Except this crossgaurd is all handle where it meets the main shaft, so a saber would just cut through
twentyfiveandone
It something like because the blades are made of energy, whenever they touch they're locked in that relative position until they disconnect.
kainslasher
Did you watch Empire Strikes back at all? Lightsaber "sliding" is how Vadar ends up cutting Luke's hand off.
mechanimated
Grievous loses an arm like that, too.
mechanimated
Frankly I'm surprised these sword masters took so long to figure out a concept as basic as a crossguard.
JPBStory
"A lot of people have an almost OBSESSIVE anger towards the lightsaber seen in the trailer" but all I've seen is people defending it.
TanstaaflTovarisch
Read this comment thread then.
JPBStory
Jesus. Point taken.
Pekku
For me it was the absolute tits. And made a lot of sense too. Haters gonna hate, etc.
BrokeMyFunnyBone
How does it make any sense?
Pekku
More defensive/offensive options. Because you don't have to parry everything with the blade.
Pekku
See an overhead slash coming? Stab them in the face and block it in one move! BAM!
BrokeMyFunnyBone
Except you can easily lop them off.
MindTheBeard
Unless they're constructed out of ANY of the like 8 lightsaber resistant materials. Which they probably are.
The5lacker
Because they're solely there to "look cool" by a 13 year old's definition of cool, which in turn compares fans to 13 year olds.
TanstaaflTovarisch
What the hell are you talking about? I'm 40 and thought they looked cool.
DonaldTrumpsPubicCombover
Crossguard* There's just one! It's the one guy's saber! No one bitched when Maul had a staff, did they?
sugar3
Shouldn't people be more concerned about the possibility, that It may be Luke holding the sword?
TanstaaflTovarisch
If they stay true at all to the EU (which it seems they are doing from a few people theorycrafting) it's not.
sugar3
I've never dabbled in the book side the Star Wars universe, I'm very interested though, any suggestions where to start?
TanstaaflTovarisch
The Thrawn trilogy would be a decent place to start.
sugar3
Very nice, will give it a geez, cheers mate!
RobotCosmonaut
Because you see all these jedi/sith doing flippy tricks with their lightsaber -- this seems like a good way to cut off your own hand
Painteagle
What if they're exhaust vents due to an unstable crystal?
kainslasher
OP tried explaining this in his last entry: Lightsabers act like an electric current. Anything enters the current, energy released, *ZWOOM*
Painteagle
I've learned so much about lightsabers over the last week. I now know that doesn't make much sense. It's still a cool idea though.
MindTheBeard
This is why they aren't exhaust vents. Pardon my paint skills. http://imgur.com/jrADeli
IDontKnowHowToHuman
I have decent understanding of science, but none of that diagram makes any sense to me. What does it have to do with not exhaust vents?
OmegaTengu
I can explain that; The battery they use it EXTREMELY efficient, it literally does not overheat.
MindTheBeard
Because in the SW Universe, it doesn't produce heat like fire. It's more like electricity. It goes from + to - and nowhere else.
ThisIsSittingOnASeal
There is no need for an exhaust. It is more of a stable reaction than a machine engine.
HandoJobrissian
My god you're a genius.
RuntCaustas
When using a real sword the blades can slide on each other and the crossguard stops the blade from sliding down to your hands.
RuntCaustas
You can also use the cross guard to grapple with and it can be used as a pick when gripped by the blade (there are safe ways to do it).
astamurti
If the wielder rotates their wrists while holding that thing, they'll cut their hands off.
TanstaaflTovarisch
Dude, he's a sith lord, bet you a nickle he doesn't.
astamurti
Use his wrists while swinging a sword, or cut his hands off?
TanstaaflTovarisch
I saw secondary buttons to turn on the crossguard blades. I'm betting that he turns them off or just spins them away from himself.
MindTheBeard
Cut his hands off. Use of a lightsaber requires something inhuman, like the force. Or multiple arms. Or cheating the system.
astamurti
I'm sure the director will use option 3, but the loss of flexibility required to not cut your hands off is horrendous.
BrokeMyFunnyBone
Cause the purpose of it is to lock the blade and prevent another blade from cutting your fingers off. These don't do that.
vowofloudness
Then perhaps that is not their purpose.
TanstaaflTovarisch
Because all the weapons I've seen in the Star Wars series have made sense...
CalvinandHobbitses
Thank you! These things aren't even possible anyway.
BrokeMyFunnyBone
No, but why seek to make even less sense?
VulcanP90
This doesn't make any less sense though. It makes as much sense as the lightsabers themselves do.
BrokeMyFunnyBone
They both don't make sense, but why make the part that would come into contact with a lightsaber the most out of a less durable material?
BrokeMyFunnyBone
They both don't make sense, but why make the part that would come into contact with a lightsaber the most out of a less durable material?
thatlamer
They don't do that, if you have little knowledge of the star wars universe, littler imagination, and assume the writers are incompetent.
BrokeMyFunnyBone
Either explain how they do that or stop trying to imply I'm wrong with vague insults.
thatlamer
There are saber resistant materials, the guard can probably be freely toggled for maneuvering, it catches any shot targeted downward at (1)
thatlamer
you hands, and unlike if the whole thing were metal, you can do real damage with it. (2)
TheFoxCouncil
http://31.media.tumblr.com/83592f622452d6547c3fb78fba04d978/tumblr_na7jcuGj4h1qm5nqro6_r2_500.gif
T8teTheGreat
I thought lightsabers could cut through anything? What's the point of a crossguard that will just get sliced off?
JakeMonkey
The EU is irrelevant at this point but there were several lightsaber resistant materials that existed within it.
Surkhan
they cant cut through a few materials in the Star Wars universe.
YourWeirdErection
The crossguard utilizes the same tech as a basic lightsaber (I.E. a Light-Crossguard) so he could halt an opponents blade with it.
MrBananaBeak
He's meaning the angle. The light beam doesn't start right next to the blade, so the mechanism is exposed.
YourWeirdErection
I saw that after i posted. Yeah, it does seem inefficient but i assume that if the guy is a sith master, that bit won't be easily targeted.
MrBananaBeak
The same reasoning could apply to why he needs a crossguard at all then.
AlwaysEatingAlmonds
The lack of a hilt in other lightsabers is what doesn't make sense to me. How does every Jedi still have forearms?
deqzel
that move would also expose the attacker, you would cut your opponents fingers/hand but he could dive the blade in your face.
tsaroth
if you think about it, several of the main characters who fight with lightsabers have had their hands cut off at least once
Ryannihilation
that, or ridiculously thick forearms. you'd have to be super strong to deflect and force back the other guy's arms before hitting yours.
lordblood123
im guessing lightsabers weren't made for fighting against other lightsabers till later and then most people just stuck with original model
baneofbelial
When two lightsabers come in contact, they stick. As far as I know, lightsaber blades can NOT slide, so the cross guard isn't an issue.
BrokeMyFunnyBone
That would still make the cross guard a dumb idea as it would present an unnecessary danger to yourself.
Ireallydonthaveanyideawhattonamemyself
It happens when dooku beats obi wan in ep2
AlwaysEatingAlmonds
Is that mentioned in the movies, or EU? And if that's the case, then ya I guess the hilt is a bit strange.
GornCaptainVS
That's funny, because they do here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7oGf-a1Dqlc&feature=youtu.be&t=2m28s
OmegaTengu
"new" trilogy fucked up things that aren't even that way in the EU.
GornCaptainVS
(around 2:25, or just open the link in a new tab)
Conradian
Actually 2:35
borkmeister
My guess is that it has something to do with Grievous not being a force wielder?
SnoozerMcGee
I imagine that if lightsabers "stick" it is a property of the lightsabers, not the users.
BeardKhan
Plot armor
wardsandcourierplz
I understand now why they decided to prune what's canon
SomeDetroitGuy
They don't want to force the movies into having to deal with the vast mounds of stuff out there. Free the movie to just be awesome.
lordblood123
still it fucking burns.
Applecrow
and then they hired JJ Abrams to make it.
JustCallMeBean
Well met, traveler.